StillPaisleyCat
@StillPaisleyCat@startrek.website
- Comment on Alex Kurtzman On His Star Trek Future: “I’m Hopeful” 1 day ago:
Given the complete failure to produce and release anything for Star Trek in more than a decade on the cinematic side, I can’t think any reasonable senior executive would think now is the time to let Kurtzman go. All the more, the historic chaos in relaunching the television franchise in the early seasons of both TNG and Discovery have demonstrated that it’s just not possible to launch a new overall franchise runner without running major risks.
Kurtzman’s got a reputation as being good to work with from both the studio/streamer and creative side. They don’t have any evidence to show he won’t adjust to new strategic direction.
The question more will be how far will Kurtzman himself be willing to compromise if the Ellisons give high level direction that would take the franchise in a very different direction for television.
What I do see is that some of the perceived failures will definitely lead to restricted opportunities for some of the EPs that have worked for Kurtzman. For example, Osunsami may not be given run of a project again after the S31 movie. Michelle Paradise won’t likely be asked to run another show in the franchise.
- Comment on Tawny Newsome Gives Update On Live-Action Star Trek Comedy – “We’re Ready!” 2 days ago:
There’s a newer TrekMovie piece, just out this afternoon, that cites a new interview with Kurtzman in an industry journal.
It also notes that a large number of of new Paramount senior executives came out for yesterday’s premiere screening.
- Comment on Tawny Newsome Gives Update On Live-Action Star Trek Comedy – “We’re Ready!” 2 days ago:
I’m not sure that it’s entirely accurate that there’s no hints of a renewal for Kurtzman’s and Secret Hideout.
In the recent SFX magazine piece for Starfleet Academy, the Kurtzman quotes hinted vaguely at “Lots more Star Trek TV is in development”.
“There’s quite a few exciting things in the works right now, but I’m not going to say more than that!”
TrekMovie observes that, ‘The SFX article noted Kurtzman was “tight-lipped about future projects,” adding that the interview was done before the announcement that[ Jonathan Goldstein and John Francis Daley are developing a new Star Trek film.’
Thinking back to the last 5-year extension, Kurtzman was asked to map out proposal for Star Trek’s television rollout for 5-7 years forward.
Clearly, he was given clearance by the new ownership to pitch stuff towards another extension. Whether there’s any uptake is to be seen.
I just keep coming back to the previous Paramount+ and streaming heads stripping the schedule back to the point that animation was being eliminated and the live action schedule was dominated by Taylor Sheridan.
Now the new owners have a large and prestigious animation studio and Sheridan refused to renew.
Meanwhile WB is fighting back against Skydance’s takeover effort to go with Netflix’s offer.
If I had to guess, Paramount+ will see more new Star Trek animation and live action as complementary to the darker whatever that the creators of Stranger Things will bring.
Kurtzman may get another but shorter extension until the movie franchise gets off the ground, but will be fenced to the 32nd century, animated shows, and shows from the 23rd and 24th century that won’t write new canon.
- Comment on Tawny Newsome Gives Update On Live-Action Star Trek Comedy – “We’re Ready!” 2 days ago:
This seems to be just one more thing in development that hinges on the decisions David Ellison will make about the next decade for the franchise, or at least the next five years.
Now that some of the new things that Ellison had been counting on to anchor Paramount+’s schedule (i.e. anything new from Taylor Sheridan) are complete nonstarters, perhaps there’s some room for some new Trek.
Also, the relationship between Kurtzman and David Ellison goes back to when Kurtzman was a writer and Ellison was a producer on Into Darkness. There’s no sense of negativity between them.
While Ellison hasn’t hesitated to finally cut the JJ Abrams movie contract that failed to meet deliverables, Kurtzman has delivered what CBS and Paramount wanted on television. There’s no reason to believe that they couldn’t come to a meeting of minds but there may be some of Secret Hideout’s long term EPs that might be let go in the process of a shift in direction.
- Comment on Starfleet Academy will broadcast on CTV Sci-fi Channel in Canada 2 days ago:
So, one of our GenZ kids has now watched the trailer a couple of times and asked some questions.
They’re not the Discovery fan among our teens, preferring animation generally. (They liked Lower Decks and Prodigy.). So, I had to fill in on the 32nd century.
They’re not entirely convinced about investing in a live action series but might watch the premiere.
Meanwhile, the one who was previously a Discovery fan has just come off a Picard and TNG watch and isn’t sounding interested. The marketing is not intriguing them the way Disco season 5 did.
All to say that I am not sure that Paramount really understands Zs or marketing to them at all.
- Comment on [Live] Star Trek: Starfleet Academy Red Carpet | Hosted by Celia Rose Gooding 2 days ago:
I found Paramount’s camera operator’s position on the ground looking up led to a lot of weird angles for the exchanges between Celia and the Starfleet Academy cast.
I also found the sound quality poor given it was their host and set up.
All of these issues made it a pain to watch.
Paramount continues to not run these events well.
- Submitted 3 days ago to startrek@startrek.website | 1 comment
- Comment on Watch: New ‘Star Trek: Starfleet Academy’ Promos Reveal Surprising Deep Cut To TOS & More 3 days ago:
I’m more suspicious that the old owners canceled all their animation so as to no be in conflict with Skydance’s animation studio which is top quality.
- Comment on ‘Star Trek: Strange New Worlds’ Casts Sulu and Bones for Series Finale 2 weeks ago:
Murakami is a theatre actor who has worked with the Royal Shakespeare Company in the UK.
IGN has details and a photo.
- Comment on Star Trek: Starfleet Academy | Exclusive Clip | Paramount+ (CCXP 2025) 3 weeks ago:
It seems logical that anyone who’s been alive eight centuries would have a unique way of speaking.
Works for me.
- Comment on Is it confirmed that The Doctor we'll be seeing in Academy is NOT the one from "Living Witness"? 3 weeks ago:
In the Relaunch novelverse, Kirsten Beyer did a great job with the post Nemesis return of Voyager to the Delta Quadrant starting with her book Full Circle.
The books exploring the post Dominion War Gamma quadrant on the other hand seemed to have promise initially, but petered out.
- Comment on Paul Giamatti Reveals Backstory For His “Over The Top” Villain On ‘Star Trek: Starfleet Academy’ 4 weeks ago:
I think that this is a spoiler that I don’t want to know before the premiere.
I can see why they need to market it every way they can though.
Their rollout is definitely showing progress compared to the last five years. The ViacomCBS/Paramount management of the shows seems to have locked everyone down but the showrunners and provided them virtually nothing for promotion.
They really are having to push back against the naysayers though. There’s been nothing but complaints on other social media that the injured cadets couldn’t use their transporters to flit themselves to sickbay.
No one seemed to have heard The Doctor say the holoemitters were out so they were short of medics.
When I hear the same complaint over and over again, it’s clearly brigading copy pasta. I doubt most of them even watched the video clip.
- Comment on 4 weeks ago:
Oooh, so much further to go…
- Comment on Star Trek: Starfleet Academy | Exclusive Clip | Paramount+ (CCXP 2025) 4 weeks ago:
I hope this clip helps to calm down all the fans out there who were outraged that Paramount’s marketing put out one key art poster targeted at another demographic.
- Comment on Master Replicas taking pre-orders for new board game Destination: Star Trek: The Next Generation 5 weeks ago:
It’s hard to know until someone reviews it.
- Comment on Get a First Look at One of WWE’s Biggest Stars in Star Trek Spin-Off ‘Starfleet Academy’ 1 month ago:
This evokes a lot of mixed feelings.
On one hand, I have no interest in wrestling and cringe at anything related to it. I’m also super uncomfortable about anything related to WWE making its way into the aspirational Star Trek franchise.
When the early wrestling shows were on local television in my childhood, my parents explained it was all performance and not real sport. So, I have always associated it with a kind of fraud and grift.
I’m always extraordinarily uneasy when young children talk about wrestling heroes as it seems an unhealthy influence. It always seems to represent a demographic that we have nothing in common with. While I’m sure some of our kids heard about WWE at school, they never expressed any interest so there was no pressure to bring anything related to it into our home — for which we were very grateful.
So, the other hand, having this strong aversion to ‘professional wrestling’, when ‘The Rock’ Dwayne Johnson first made his dramatic acting appearance on Star Trek Voyager, I was so annoyed that I didn’t watch the episode.
I realize now that I let my strong bias against the performance of ‘wrestling’ get in the way of assessing an actor on his own merit.
I also recognize that Secret Hideout has been doing its best to bring in actors that will appeal to demographics that are likely to be critical of Starfleet Academy while retaining true diversity.
So, I’m going to try to swallow my aversion and wish this woman performer success as she tries to break out of the WWE circuit.
(I still think Paramount+ senior executives are trying to do everything they can to make our household drop our subscription.)
- Comment on The Strange New Worlds Season 3 Soundtrack has been released 1 month ago:
Even my GenZ kids ask for they physical media not the digital.
Our youngest was just this afternoon sincerely explaining to me why they want their Nintendo games as cards not digital copies.
- Comment on [deleted] 2 months ago:
I’ve done it through DDG on my phone. Still get weird thumbnail.
When I can get on desktop, I can try again but it really makes me wonder about CBR.
- Comment on [deleted] 2 months ago:
Even with the now corrected link, it still wants to show the image from the ad.
I stripped the tracking code from the end but the other image won’t clear.
- Comment on [deleted] 2 months ago:
Corrected it. I initially seemed to have picked up the ad instead of the actual interview.
- Comment on Star Trek: Starfleet Academy | Official Trailer | Paramount+ (NYCC 2025) 2 months ago:
I’m not sure why anyone ever thought it would be?
Other than the naysayers who were looking not to like it and had to be ‘shown otherwise.’
Even Prodigy ended up an ‘all ages’ show.
In this case, despite the idea of an Academy show kicking around since the 1970s, it was fairly clear that no senior network/streamer executive were ever going greenlight it until someone came up with a concept that was more than a college soap in the Star Trek universe.
What I didn’t expect was for the other perennial ‘failed to make it to pilot’ franchise idea of a hospital show also got rolled into it. That’s one that Roddenberry first tried to spin off with M’Benga in the second season of TOS.
- Comment on Podcast Discussion | Star Trek: Khan | 1x01 "Paradise" 2 months ago:
I’m finally getting back to this.
Had a work push and then a virus. I really find I have even less attention for listening and podcasts when I’m ill.
One thing that I’ve figured out is that the audio quality varies widely depending on the service one is getting podcasts from or the delivery app.
The base recording is excellent and the sound effects are there. Some of the players have so much noise that you’d never realize that.
In any event, I tried out different players and found that Cassidy’s delivery was much less mumbly on better audio players regardless of being on the same device.
Something to consider when getting podcasts even through open source players.
- Comment on Star Trek: Starfleet Academy | Official Trailer | Paramount+ (NYCC 2025) 2 months ago:
We can disagree on that.
I will never love TMP but I will never claim it’s not Star Trek.
- Comment on Star Trek: Starfleet Academy | Official Trailer | Paramount+ (NYCC 2025) 2 months ago:
I agree. These folks have no perspective or are dishonest with themselves.
I can acknowledge that it can be jarring, and it can take time to accept a major visual design update.
I felt that in 1979 as I sat in the theatre watching Star Trek: The Motion Picture.
I had no heads up whatsoever that the Klingon design had changed. I was completely confused in the opening scenes with the Klingons. I couldn’t figure out what species they were.
But I got over it. Quickly.
I still think TMP is disappointing, long boring movie that rehashes the Nomad plot from TOS. The Klingon redesign wasn’t its problem though.
- Comment on Stephen Colbert Reveals ‘Star Trek: Starfleet Academy’ Role As Paramount+ Sets Premiere Date — NYCC 2 months ago:
It seems more that Larry Ellison is giving his adult children amounts of money to invest to learn how to run businesses.
Amounts that for most others would be an inheritance in themselves are less than a year’s interest on Larry’s overall fortune.
David and his sister both started out with a certain amount.
His sister’s firm got into financial difficulties so Larry appointed a co head and hasn’t invested more.
David made his investment in creating Skydance profitable and so his father is investing more.
It’s a better solution than Trump taking his cut of the inheritance and bankrupting it, and then getting full control and bankrupting again.
That’s not to say even so that Larry isn’t taking advantage of the CBS part of the purchase to reshape its news to his own vision.
- Comment on ‘Star Trek: Strange New Worlds’ Cast And EPs Talk “Going For Broke” In Season 4, “Bittersweet” Season 5 2 months ago:
Celia’s hair for the panel suggests they’re evolving Uhura’s style in season five towards the one in TOS.
Which is interesting because Celia really wanted to avoid wigs and keep a natural hairstyle.
I’m wondering what kind of hair Jess will have for Chappel in the final season.
- Comment on Star Trek: Starfleet Academy | Official Trailer | Paramount+ (NYCC 2025) 2 months ago:
There are a bunch of the perennial brigading naysayers on other platforms already venting that this young Klingon is too skinny/lanky.
Seems that they never saw Tony Todd as Kurn or considered that TALL is an important Klingon physical characteristic.
- Comment on Star Trek: Starfleet Academy | Official Trailer | Paramount+ (NYCC 2025) 2 months ago:
This comes across as gatekeeping…
— from the perspective of someone who’s been watching Trek since the 1960s and has seen the same old ‘ahem, not Trek, it’s stealing from …’ chestnuts since TAS was announced, I am alway surprised how little older fans recognize that Trek has ALWAYS adapted other media (movies, television, radio plays, Shakespeare!) into its episodesz
Sigh.
- Comment on LIVE | Star Trek Universe Panel at New York Comic Con 2025 2 months ago:
They’re making sure they’ll hit the February sweeps for advertiser data (which weirdly remain a thing in the streaming era).
Perhaps the new ownership are going to give the franchise more of a chance to thrive.
- Comment on Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | BTS: Season 3 Costumes | Paramount+ (NYCC 2025) 2 months ago:
Never any notes on the SNW costumes.
