This is an automated archive made by the Lemmit Bot.
The original was posted on /r/cfb by /u/dfphd on 2025-09-14 17:08:22+00:00.
Just picking this list from ESPN which generally tracks with the consensus:
Tier 1:
- Klubnik
- Nussmeier
- Mateer
- Allar
- Sellers
Tier 2:
- Lagway
- Beck
- Manning
Through week 3, looking at QBR - to pick a metric that covers passing, rushing, and is opponent adjusted. I know QBR isn’t perfect, but in this case it generally tracks with what we’re seeing:
5 Carson Beck - and he has looked legit good.
27 Mateer who has also looked legit good.
37 Nussmeier has been… alright. Like, he hasn’t been bad, but he’s nowhere near the 1st round pick level we were talking about preseason.
After that?
76 Lagway - ass
88 Manning - ass
100 Klubnik - ass
104 Sellers - … dare I say ass?
111 Allar - ass
Like, I understand there will be some controversy over the specific ranking of those last 5, but that’s not what I care about - I mostly just care about them all being nowhere near the best QBs in football.
That entire group should be thankful that Manning has been that overhyped and that bad because they’re not catching nearly as much heat as they would if he wasn’t in the picture.