This is an automated archive made by the Lemmit Bot.

The original was posted on /r/nfl by /u/Elend15 on 2023-09-02 23:58:32.

In 2022, Geno was:

  1. 6th in Passer rating

  2. 7th in QBR

  3. 2nd in completion % (only behind Bailey Zapper)

  4. 8th in passing yards

  5. 9th in Y/A (among QBs that played 10 or more games)

  6. 4th in TDs

  7. Had a TD:INT ratio of 3:1

  8. 1st in deep pass accuracy

I get there’s a skepticism that he will repeat those feats. But were those not top 10, even top 7 or so QB metrics?

What are the arguments against him being an elite QB in 2022? And then again in 2023?

And what defines an “elite” QB? Do they need to be as good as the Elite Dragon?