The original post: /r/television by /u/disasterpansexual on 2024-06-15 10:26:05.

for me it’s equal to S1 in quality, here’s the complete breakdown

RUSSEL T. DAVIES ERA

9th - Christopher Eccleston

  • S1   ☆☆☆☆.25 (love 9!!! I wish he lasted longer)

10th - David Tennant

  • S2   ☆☆☆.5 (pretty boring, ngl)
  • S3   ☆☆☆.75 (not bad, but not as good as 5 or 6)
  • S4   ☆☆☆☆☆ (best duo!!! TEN finally went on full potential)

STEVEN MOFFAT ERA

11th - Matt Smith

  • S5   ☆☆☆☆☆ (PERFECTION!!!)
  • S6   ☆☆☆☆ (a bit boring in the beginning, but good second half)
  • S7   ☆☆☆.75 (first half was good, second half was boring)

12th - Peter Capaldi

  • S8   ☆☆☆☆☆ (love this!! I love 12 abs and the pacing is amazing)
  • S9   ☆☆☆☆.25 (would have been 4 but the ending was insane!)
  • S10 ☆☆☆.75 (pretty mid, but amazing finale)

CHRIS CHIBNALL ERA

13th - Jodie Whittaker

  • S11:
  • S12:
  • S13:

RUSSEL T. DAVIES ERA

14th - David Tennant

  • 60TH    ☆☆☆☆ (nice and fun, tho they didn’t feel really anniversaries)

15th - Ncuti Gatwa

  • S14    ☆☆☆☆.5 (loved this!!!)

AVERAGE RATING FOR SHOWRUNNERS

  • RTD1 average ranking: 4.1
  • MOFFAT      "       "      : 4.3
  • CHIBNALL  "       "      :
  • RTD2 " " : 4.2

SEASONS RANK:

  • S05 - 5
  • S04 - 5
  • S08 - 5
  • S01 - 4.5
  • S14 - 4.5
  • S09 - 4.25
  • S06 - 4
  • S07 - 3.75
  • S10 - 3.75
  • S03 - 3.75
  • S02 - 3.5

                                                NOTES                                               

  • 4&5 are very close but 11 is just my fav so S5 goes above
  • 8 is amazing but a tiny bit under 4&5
  • 6 & 9 are very close but 9 is a tiny bit better because of the insanely good finale
  • 7, 3 & 10 are very close: 7 has a good first half but a bad second half; 3 is a bit better overall (but never go as good as first half of 7, while 10 is mid but has a great finale…(but overall Matt is my fav Doctor, so 7 is more dear to me)

DOCTORS RANK

  • 11th     ☆☆☆☆☆     PERFECTION!!! HE’S SO CUTE AND FUNNY AND REALLY GETS SOME OF THE BEST EPISODES (AND COMPANIONS)
  • 12th    ☆☆☆☆.5       HE’S AMAZING!!! SO SAD, CYNICAL, DARK, YET WEIRD AND FUNNY, AND SO FERAL. + HE’S INSPIRED BY DAVID BOWIE!!! I LOVE MY ALIEN ROCKSTAR!!!
  • 9th       ☆☆☆☆.5   SO GOOD!!! WISHED WOULD HAVE LASTED LONGER
  • 9th       ☆☆☆☆.5      STILL TOO LITTLE TIME TO JUDGE BUT I’M LOVING HIM!!
  • 10th     ☆☆☆☆         GREAT PERFORMANCE, BUT NOT AS DEAR TO ME AS THE OTHERS, MOSTLY BECAUSE HE GOT ON FULL POTENTIAL ONLY IN S4 WITH THE AMAZING DONNA

COMPANIONS RATING

  • Rose                   ☆☆☆☆.5
  • Martha               ☆☆.5
  • Donna                ☆☆☆☆☆
  • Amy & Rory       ☆☆☆☆☆
  • Clara                   ☆☆☆☆
  • Bill & Nardole    ☆☆☆.5
  • Ruby Sunday     ☆☆☆☆