Obviously all of those instances are different.
What a stupid question.

And not just somehow.
They are measurably different by time, context and by how systemic the suppression of whole populations was organized.

I am not even a big fan of reparation payments myself but your strawman bashing is embarrassing.

And the simple point is.
If you are a white American or European (like I am myself btw) you, yes you personally, profit from privileges that this group accumulated over many generations by suppressing and exploiting other groups.

Europe was super horrible early and in the US there are still people alive today that couldn’t visit restaurants and had to sit in the back of the bus.

But hey if we wait another 100 years without any reparations our grandkids can claim that those thing are too long ago also.