Comment on Why are US states, school districts banning smartphones in schools?

<- View Parent
blindsight@beehaw.org ⁨5⁩ ⁨months⁩ ago

You’re only considering one narrow use of LLMs (which they’re bad at). They’re great for things like idea generation, formatting, restructuring text, and other uses.

For example, I tend to write at too high a writing level. I know this about myself, but it’s still hard (with my ADHD) to remain mindful of that while also focusing on everything else that crowds my working memory when doing difficult work. I also know that I tend to focus more on what students can improve instead of what they did well.

So ChatGPT is a great tool for me to get a first pass of feedback for students. I can then copy/paste the oats I agree with for praise, then “turd sandwich” my suggestions for improvement in the middle.

For tests, it’s great to get it to generate a list of essay questions. You can feed GPT 4 up to 50 pages of text, too, so the content is usually really accurate if you actually know how to write good prompts.

I could go on. LLMs are a great tool, and teachers are professionals who (I hope) are using it appropriately. (Not just blindly copying/pasting like our students are… But that’s a whole other topic.)

source
Sort:hotnewtop