Comment on Why Furiosa’s CGI Looks More Fake Than Mad Max Fury Road
maegul@lemmy.ml 7 months ago
I’m an annoying broken record on this ATM (genuinely sorry, but I’m happy to die on this hill for now) …
but maybe being amateur VFX critics is not the best thing we could be doing with a movie going experiences?! How was the story, writing, directing and the acting?!!
I’ve recently started watching Babylon 5, a 90s Sci-Fi show. The props are cheap, and all of the space scenes are done with TV 90s CGI that basically looks like a video game … from '94. And so far (about half way through season 1), I’m all in. I got used to the VFX and have even come to appreciate their “charm” (seriously, they look kinda alien and comic book like) … but mostly I like the story, directing and characters … focusing on the CGI would be a waste of my time … they tell the space elements of the story perfectly well.
Now I haven’t seen Furiosa, and I’m open to it and its VFX being poorly deployed … but maybe this whole “the CGI took me out of it because I could tell it wasn’t practical … is just missing the point”??
EndHD@lemm.ee 7 months ago
I think they criticise VFX because there’s an end goal of being indistinguishable from reality.
Commenting on story, execution, and uniqueness requires actual taste and a personal bias which may least to reduced views and interaction.