Comment on I'm on Lemmy to commiepost and chew bubblegum. And I'm all out of gum.
perturbedstarstuff@lemmy.world 2 days agoIDK much about communism, but what I do know I learned from an anticommunist propagandist fiction writer.
Another normal day.
deadalus@discuss.tchncs.de 2 days ago
You can’t be referring to Orwell here, can you?
Cowbee@lemmy.ml 1 day ago
Who else would they be referring to? The central point of Animal Farm is that workers are stupid and incapable of understanding their own conditions, and thus will endlessly be taken advantage of by charismatic leaders. It’s a deeply aristocratic take that erases the agency of the working classes. Orwell was also a snitch, keeping lists of Jews and communists to report to the British feds. Fuck Orwell. That’s all without getting into the allegations that he was a sex abuser when he was young as well.
deadalus@discuss.tchncs.de 9 hours ago
Yeah, lemmy.ml checks out. The point of animal farm was specifically to show how Stalin betrayed the Revolution for his own gains. You got Trotsky as snowball, Stalin as Napoleon and Lenin as Old mayor.
It’s about how people have to be careful who to give too much power, and how easily the public can be deceived. In the end it shows the pigs walking upright and partying with the humans, who were an allegory for the capitalists. Because the ruling class wasn’t abolished, it was merely replaced by party officials
Cowbee@lemmy.ml 9 hours ago
Yep, you nailed the intention of Orwell, who was an awful person to begin with. He was, after all, a fierce anti-communist and snitch. I’m aware of the allegorical ties to Stalin, Trotsky, and Old Major being a mix of Marx and Lenin, as are most people. However, reading the book, you can clearly see that everything rests on a central thesis:
The working class, specifically the Russian working class, is mind-bogglingly stupid, helpless, and cannot think for themselves to save their own lives, and are therefore destined to be taken advantage of.
This isn’t a stretch in any capacity. Orwell had a very aristocratic attitude towards the working class, and considered himself better than them (see the linked article below). Here’s how he describes workers in Animal Farm, taken from *A Critical Read of Animal Farm:
The entire essay is fantastic. And yes, I obviously have issues with how Orwell depicts Marxism, because I myself am a Marxist-Leninist. His works were promoted by the CIA to discredit communism and socialism in the eyes of the working class, it’s why everybody knows about 1984 and Animal Farm. Hell, Isaac Asimov absolutely hated 1984 for being a horrendous understanding of politics, so it’s not like it’s only Marxists that gave an issue with Orwell’s work
I recommend you reject Orwell’s aristocratic “socialism” and believe in the abilities of the working class. We already run the world, we should own it, too.