If you let them keep secret what they do in the bathroom, they will make all corrupt deals in the bathroom. People can’t be trusted with both power over thousands or millions of lives and the ability to keep secrets.
And as for fickle voters, if they want to change their mind, fine. Better to have a more representative system, a system based in reality, than to pretend the ‘leaders’ (read ‘people who said they wanted power’) can be trusted not to burn the world for their own benefit.