The American model of free speech is anything but. It’s a narrative cover over reality.

The US government has always and will always choose what speech is unacceptable and repress it. They have been doing so for centuries. They have killed so many people for speaking. They have entire departments dedicated to media manipulation and censorship. They have vast financial incentives organized by the government to limit speech. There have been at least 2 open purges of communists and a third purge is burgeoning as we speak.

The American model is not actually that the government should have the power to limit speech but rather that the government will limit violent speech if it goes against the government’s goals and will protect violent speech if it supports the government’s goals. That’s why white supremacist hate speech is protected in the US - no because America is a shining beacon of free speech but because America is shining beacon of white supremacy.