Comment on Trick question
ramble81@lemmy.zip 4 days agoLook, you’re not going to get perfect, and if you can figure it out, I have a Nobel Peace Prize for you. But at least something that is causing the loss of more land and the genocide of their people is a hell of a better place to be.
geneva_convenience@lemmy.ml 4 days ago
All of the Palestinian land back to the Palestinians whose land was stolen. Unless they agree to something different it’s all rightfully theirs.
stsquad@lemmy.ml 4 days ago
Good luck with that - but entirely unrealistic. You have to deal with the demographics as they are and not with them at some arbitrary point in the past.
After you’ve solved Palistine are you going to have a crack at unwinding the effects of colonialism around the rest of the world?
geneva_convenience@lemmy.ml 4 days ago
And a genocidal expansionist Apartheid around the corner is realistic? Like keeping Nazi Germany around the corner after 1945. Surely that can’t go wrong. Your idea is much less realistic than mine.
ramble81@lemmy.zip 3 days ago
There’s idealistic and then there’s pragmatic. Following that logic, what are you going to do about lands stolen from Native Americans, or anything as a result of colonialism? “Give them back!” you say. Which may be done idealistically, but in the US for example, where does the other population of 330 Million people go?
You’re basically advocating for genocide in a different way with a different winner. That’s not a sustainable or realistic outcome.