Comment on ChatGPT Is Still a Bullshit Machine
DaddleDew@lemmy.world 2 days ago
The whole technology is based on a flawed simulation of intelligence. It has no understanding of the meaning of what it is saying. It will always be bullshitting.
Comment on ChatGPT Is Still a Bullshit Machine
DaddleDew@lemmy.world 2 days ago
The whole technology is based on a flawed simulation of intelligence. It has no understanding of the meaning of what it is saying. It will always be bullshitting.
mindbleach@sh.itjust.works 8 hours ago
This kind of assertion wildly overestimates how well we understand intelligence.
Higher levels of bullshitting require more abstraction and self-reference. Meaning must be inferred from observation, to make certain decisions, even when picking words from a list.
Current models are abstract enough to see a chessboard in an Atari screenshot, figure out which pieces each jumble of pixels represents, and provide a valid move. Scoffing because it’s not actually good at chess is a bizarre line to draw, to say there’s zero understanding involved.
Current models might be abstract enough to teach them a new game by explaining the rules.
Current models are not abstract enough to explain why they’re bad at a game and expect them to improve.