I feel this way about so many indie games.

• Praey for the Gods - Obviously inspired by the classic, Shadow of the Collosus
• The Upturned - A horror-comedy game with a great sense of humor
• Your Spider - A great indie horror game with puzzles like Silent Hill. Plus it has an adorable spider. This is one of my favorite indie horror games.
• Exanima - Looks at first like a normal dungeon crawler, but its physics-based combat controls and enemy AI make this a very unique and interesting game, even if it’s been in early access for ages.
• Withering Rooms - Great, creepy atmosphere and an interesting story.